The LINGUIST List is dedicated to providing information on language and language analysis, and to providing the discipline of linguistics with the infrastructure necessary to function in the digital world. LINGUIST is a free resource, run by linguistics students and faculty, and supported primarily by your donations. Please support LINGUIST List during the 2016 Fund Drive.
Ask-A-Linguist Message Details
|Subject:||Best approach to teaching a child Russian in a monolingual English environment|
|Question:||Hello, I am Russian but I permanently live in the UK with English husband and a baby boy. I'm really eager for my son to speak boy Russian and English but I am concerned whether my approach is the best. I am a stay-at-home mum at the moment and I speak Russian to my son as much as I can. Sadly, it is not always possible to follow a strict ''One Parent One Language'' method. I'd love to only speak Russian to my boy and for my husband to only speak English, but living in the UK means we go to English- speaking baby groups (including singing English songs at our local library at a reading group), we meet English friends and even at home my husband and I communicate in English between us. Surely, he should be exposed to being with other children and adults a lot in order to develop his social skills, too. I try really hard to surround my boy with Russian as much as I can (talking to him as much as possible, reading Russian books and singing Russian songs, speaking to his grandparents frequently and for long) but unfortunately I do not speak Russian exclusively to him. Is it going to be a major problem for his learning of Russian? I worry at some point he might refuse to speak it to me since he knows I also speak English on some occassions. My husband does not speak Russian fluently, so we cannot make it our family language at home. Please, would you advise to me the best approach? Thank you so much in advance.|
|Reply:||As you will see from my FAQ on this topic, I feel that the 'One Parent One Language' slogan has been promoted as if it is the best and/or the only way to promote bilingual children. It isn't. There are many ways. I've never understood how OPOL works in the real world and I don't know how its proponents have made it so popular a recommendation when it is so unusual in the real world. Of course you have to live normally in the place you are and of course he has to socialise with other children and adults. Of course you have to have a social life and have to converse with your husband. Just go on doing it and don't feel guilty. Generally, where it is the mother who speaks the language that is not supported in the community, the child is more likely to keep using the language than if it is the father. So it seems to me that (as long as you continue to spend more time with your son than his father) it is highly likely that your son will learn Russian well and will retain it. It is possible that at some point (aged 3 or 4) he may reject Russian -- if he does, you will just have to cope with it then. But he might never reject it. And keep going with the grandparents, Skype, visits, media.... Anthea|
|Reply From:||Anthea Fraser Gupta click here to access email|