LINGUIST List 17.3496
|
Sun Nov 26 2006
Diss: Discourse Analysis/Cognitive Science: Pang: 'A Partitioned-Na...'
Editor for this issue: Hannah Morales
<hannah linguistlist.org>
|
To post to LINGUIST, use our convenient web form at
http://linguistlist.org/LL/posttolinguist.html.
|
Directory
1. Kam-yiu
Pang,
A Partitioned-Narrative Model of the Self: Its linguistic manifestations, entailments, and ramifications
Message 1: A Partitioned-Narrative Model of the Self: Its linguistic manifestations, entailments, and ramifications
|
Date: 25-Nov-2006
From: Kam-yiu Pang <kamyiu.panggmail.com>
Subject: A Partitioned-Narrative Model of the Self: Its linguistic manifestations, entailments, and ramifications
Institution: University of Otago
Program: Linguistics Section
Dissertation Status: Completed
Degree Date: 2006
Author: Kam-Yiu S. Pang
Dissertation Title: A Partitioned-Narrative Model of the Self: Its linguistic manifestations, entailments, and ramifications
Linguistic Field(s):
Cognitive Science
Discourse Analysis
Philosophy of Language
Semantics
Dissertation Director:
Chris Ackerley
Jae Jung Song
John R Taylor
Dissertation Abstract:
Contrary to common folk and expert theory, the human self is not unitary.
There is no Cartesian theatre or homunculus functioning as a metaphorical
overlord. Rather, it is an abstractum gleaned from a person's experiences—a
centre of narrative gravity (Dennett 1991). Experiences are a person's
cognisance of her ventures in life from a particular unique perspective. In
perspectivising her experiences, the person imputes a certain structure,
order, and significance to them. Events are seen as unfolding in a certain
inherently and internally coherent way characterised by causality,
temporality, or intentionality, etc. In other words, a person's self
emerges out of her innumerable narrativisations of experience, as well as
the different protagonist roles she plays in them. Her behaviours in
different situations can be understood as different life-narratives being
foregrounded, when she is faced with different stimuli which different
experiences/events present.
In real life, self-reflective discourse frequently alludes to a divided,
partitive self, and the experiences/behaviours that it can engage in. In
academic study, this concept of the divided and narrative-constructivist
self is well-represented in disciplines ranging from philosophy (e.g.,
Dennett 1991, 2005), developmental psychology (e.g., Markus & Nurius 1986;
Bruner 1990, 2001; Stern 1994), cognitive psychology (e.g., Hermans &
Kempen 1993; Hermans 2002), neuropsychology (e.g. Damasio 1999), psychiatry
(e.g., Feinberg 2001), to linguistics (e.g., McNeil 1996; Ochs & Capps
1996; Nair 2003). Depending on the particular theory, however, emphasis is
often placed either on its divided or its narrative-constructivist nature.
This thesis argues, however, that the two are coexistent and
interdependent, and both are essential to the self's ontology. Its
objectives are therefore: (i) to propose a partitioned-narrative model of
the self which unifies the two perspectives by positing that the
partitioned-representational (Dinsmore 1991) nature of narratives entails
the partitioned structure of the self; and (ii) to propose that the
partitioned-narrative ontology of the self is what enables and motivates
much of our self-reflective discourse and the grammatical resources for
constructing that discourse. Partitioning guarantees that a part of the
self, i.e., one of its narratives, can be selectively attended to,
foregrounded, objectified, and hence talked about. Narrativity provides the
contextual guidance and constraints for meaning-construction in such
discourse. This claim is substantiated with three application cases:
reflexivity ('I found myself smiling'); various usages of proper names,
including eponyms ('the Shakespeare of architecture'), eponymic denominal
adjectives ('Herculean'), etc.; and partitive-self constructions which
explicitly profile partitioned and selectively focal narratives ('That's
his hormones talking'). When analysed using the proposed model, these
apparently disparate behaviours turn out to share a common basis: the
partitioned-narrative self.
Respond to list|Read more issues|LINGUIST home page|Top of issue
|
|
Please report any bad links or misclassified data
LINGUIST Homepage | Read
LINGUIST | Contact us
While the LINGUIST List makes every effort to ensure the linguistic relevance of sites listed
on its pages, it cannot vouch for their contents.
|
|
