Date: 08-Nov-2007 From: Ulrich Lueders <lincom.europat-online.de> Subject: Norwegian Examples in International Linguistics Literature: Engh E-mail this message to a friend
Title: Norwegian Examples in International Linguistics Literature
Subtitle: An inventory of defective documentation
Series Title: Linguistics Edition 62
Published: 2007
Publisher: Lincom GmbH
http://www.lincom.eu
Author: Jan Engh
Paperback: ISBN: 9783895868566 Pages: 170 Price: Europe EURO 54.00
Abstract:
This is an inventory of examples of incorrect Norwegian used by foreign linguists in international theoretical linguistics literature. It is the result of a search of several volumes of 18 journals and some 1500 printed books. It consists of approximately 346 excerpts, each containing at least one case of deficient documentation, made by 139 linguists under 167 titles. The excerpts contain a rich variety of errors, ranging from character representation errors and mere misspellings to sheer nonsense. The extent of the deficient documentation is astonishing as well: More than two thirds of all the articles, books etc. with Norwegian material written by foreign theoretical linguists contained errors (even when the less offensive ones are not taken into consideration).
In most cases, the excerpts contain many errors, frequently errors pertaining to various levels of description (characters, morphology, syntax etc.). Moreover, identical errors may appear in subsequent versions of the same text or in other texts by the same author. Although most of these errors seem trivial considered separately, their negative importance increases as a consequence of their quantity both for the individual linguist and for linguistics on the whole, thus highlighting the problematic relationship between current theoretical linguistics and its empirical base. This inevitably raises doubts as to the validity of the theoretical arguments that the examples are meant to support - and the standards of linguistics' publishing.
Linguistic Field(s):
Discipline of Linguistics
General Linguistics
linguistlist.org>
E-mail this message to a friend
