LINGUIST List 23.4712|
Sun Nov 11 2012
Diss: Language Acquisition: Bailey: 'Second Language lexical Acquisition...'
Editor for this issue: Lili Xia
From: Paul Bailey <paulebaileygmail.com>
Subject: Second Language lexical Acquisition: A matter of depth of processing or of multiple retrieval?
E-mail this message to a friend
Institution: Swansea University
Program: Ph.D. Applied Linguistics
Dissertation Status: Completed
Degree Date: 2012
Author: Paul Bailey
Dissertation Title: Second Language lexical Acquisition: A matter of depth of processing or of multiple retrieval?
This thesis investigates the predictions of Barcroft's type of processing-
resource allocation (TOPRA) model. The TOPRA model contends that
in order to learn a second/foreign language word, one must complete
three subprocesses. These are processing for form, processing for
meaning, and form-meaning mapping. The model posits that
corresponding amounts of one of these types of processing leads to
corresponding amounts of learning. Thus, semantic processing will
lead to the learning of meanings, while structural processing will lead to
the learning of word forms. The model contends that human beings are
limited capacity processers, so in learning a foreign language,
excessive processing in one of these areas drains resources that could
be used for processing and subsequent learning in other areas.
Therefore, excessive semantic processing can be detrimental to
learning the structural properties of a word during the initial stages of
foreign language lexical acquisition. Indeed, the main thrust of
Barcroft's research in the area has been to demonstrate the
detrimental effects of semantic processing. He has proposed that
learners should not be forced to undertake activities involving semantic
elaboration during the initial stages of learning new words. The series
of studies conducted during the present thesis found some support for
the predictions of the TOPRA model when Barcroft's experimental
paradigm was followed. However, at the same time, the studies here
found many conflicting results to the predictions of the model.
Therefore, the scope of the model seems to be limited. Furthermore, it
is contended that multiple retrieval of words rather than the amount of
their structural or semantic processing is a more important determinant
of second language lexical acquisition.
Read more issues|LINGUIST home page|Top of issue
Page Updated: 11-Nov-2012
While the LINGUIST List makes every effort to ensure the linguistic relevance of sites listed
on its pages, it cannot vouch for their contents.