Publishing Partner: Cambridge University Press CUP Extra Publisher Login
amazon logo
More Info


New from Oxford University Press!

ad

The Language Hoax

By John H. McWhorter

The Language Hoax "argues that that all humans process life the same way, regardless of their language."


New from Cambridge University Press!

ad

Language and Development in Africa

By H. Ekkehard Wolff

Language and Development in Africa "discusses the resourcefulness of languages, both local and global, in view of the ongoing transformation of African societies as much as for economic development.. "


The LINGUIST List is dedicated to providing information on language and language analysis, and to providing the discipline of linguistics with the infrastructure necessary to function in the digital world. LINGUIST is a free resource, run by linguistics students and faculty, and supported primarily by your donations. Please support LINGUIST List during the 2016 Fund Drive.

Summary Details


Query:   Sum: Parallel multilingual wordlists
Author:  Daniel Wedgwood
Submitter Email:  click here to access email
Linguistic LingField(s):   Lexicography

Summary:   ABOUT A MONTH AGO I POSTED AN ENQUIRY (LINGUIST 14.1083) ABOUT THE AVAILABILITY OF PARALLEL WORD LISTS (AS OPPOSED TO LISTS OF COGNATES) IN DIFFERENT LANGUAGES. I GOT THE IMPRESSION FROM SOME OF THE RESPONSES THAT THERE ARE OTHERS OUT THERE WHO WOULD APPRECIATE AS MUCH INFORMATION ON THIS AS POSSIBLE, SO I'M INCLUDING HERE NOT JUST A SUMMARY OF RESPONSES BUT ALSO SOME SOURCES OF DATA THAT I FOUND BY OTHER MEANS.

MANY THANKS TO EVERYONE WHO RESPONDED. HERE IS A SUMMARY OF THE RESPONSES:

ROBIN THELWALL KINDLY OFFERED OFFPRINTS AND REFERENCES RELATING TO WORK DONE BY HIMSELF AND OTHERS CONTAINING LISTS FOR A NUMBER OF NILO-SAHARAN LANGUAGES AND ''VARIOUS BITS OF BANTU''.

RADMILA DJORDJEVIC POINTED OUT THE EXISTENCE OF BERLITZ MULTILINGUAL EUROPEAN DICTIONARIES, WHICH ARE PRIMARILY AIMED AT TOURISTS, BUT COULD BE OF USE TO LINGUISTS SEEKING PARALLEL DATA FOR MULTIPLE LANGUAGES.

YURI KORYAKOV SUGGESTED LOOKING AT THE VERY RICH SOURCE OF MULTILINGUAL VOCABULARY DATA ON SERGEI STAROSTIN'S BABEL TOWER WEBSITE:
HTTP://STARLING.RINET.RU/DOWNLOAD.HTM

THIS TURNS OUT TO BE ORGANISED GENERALLY AROUND COGNATES, SO YURI WAS KIND ENOUGH TO SEND A NUMBER OF 100-WORD SWADESH LISTS WHICH HE HAS IN FILES IN .DBF FORMAT.

NATALIA SLASKA SENT POINTERS TO A LARGE NUMBER OF USEFUL RESOURCES. FIRST, THE WEBSITE OF THE PROJECT THAT SHE IS INVOLVED IN, WHICH WILL INTEREST PEOPLE WHO ARE WORKING WITH WORD LISTS FOR HISTORICAL LINGUISTIC PURPOSES:
HTTP://WWW.SHEF.AC.UK/ENGLISH/LANGUAGE/QUANTLING/INDEX.HTML

SECOND, AN EXTREMELY USEFUL SET OF REFERENCES TO PRINTED WORKS CONTAINING SWADESH LISTS FOR VARIOUS LANGUAGES. MANY ARE FROM ISSUES OF IJAL FROM THE 1950S AND 60S. SPACE DOESN'T ALLOW ME TO REPRODUCE ALL THE REFERENCES HERE; I'D BE HAPPY TO FORWARD THEM TO ANYONE WHO
ASKS.

TO ALL THESE VERYUSEFUL SUGGESTIONS, I WOULD ADD THE FOLLOWING RESOURCES: HTTP://WWW.ROSETTAPROJECT.ORG HAS A DATABASE OF SWADESH LISTS FOR A WIDE VARIETY OF LANGUAGES, BUT FEW OF THEM ARE COMPLETE.

DYEN, ISIDORE, JOSEPH B KRUSKAL, AND PAUL BLACK (1992) AN INDOEUROPEAN CLASSIFICATION: A LEXICOSTATISTICAL EXPERIMENT, TRANSACTIONS OF THE AMERICAN PHILOSOPHICAL SOCIETY, VOL. 82, PART 5. LARGE DATA SET (95 LANGUAGES/DIALECTS) AVAILABLE ONLINE AT:
HTTP://WWW.WORDGUMBO.COM/IE/CMP/IEDATA.TXT

ALSO AT WWW.WORDGUMBO.COM IS A COLLECTION OF LISTS TAKEN FROM VARIOUS SMALL ONLINE DICTIONARIES - THESE ARE NOT IDENTICAL LISTS, BUT MANY OVERLAP TO A WORTHWHILE EXTENT.

JACQUES GUY'S GLOTTO PROGRAM COMES WITH 200-WORD LISTS FOR 16 INDOEUROPEAN LANGUAGES. THE MEANINGS ARE NOT THE SWADESH LIST, BUT MAINLY NOUNS TAKEN FROM BERGMAN, PETER (1968) THE CONCISE DICTIONARY OF 26 LANGUAGES IN SIMULTANEOUS TRANSLATION, SIGNET BOOKS. FOR ONLINE
AVAILABILITY, SEE GUY'S POSTING TO THE LINGUIST LIST, (LINGUIST 5.630).

1600-WORD LISTS FOR ENGLISH, ITALIAN, GERMAN, DUTCH AND THE INVENTED LANGUAGES ESPERANTO, NOVIAL AND TSOLYANI CAN BE DOWNLOADED FROM
HTTP://WWW.INVISIBLELIGHTHOUSE.COM/ULD/ULD2.HTML
(PERMISSION IS REQUESTED BY THE WEBSITE OWNER FOR USE OF THESE DATA IN
RESEARCH.)

200-WORD LISTS FOR 7 LANGUAGES USED IN KESSLER, B. (2001) THE SIGNIFICANCE OF WORD LISTS, STANFORD: CENTER FOR THE STUDY OF LANGUAGE AND INFORMATION. ARE AVAILABLE AS A WELL-ANNOTATED XML FILE FROM BRETT KESSLER'S WEBSITE:
HTTP://WWW.ARTSCI.WUSTL.EDU/~BKESSLER/

TRYON, DARREL (1995) COMPARATIVE AUSTRONESIAN DICTIONARY. BERLIN: MOUTON DE GRUYTER. IS APPARENTLY A POSSIBLE SOURCE OF PARALLEL WORD LISTS FOR AUSTRONESIAN LANGUAGES (I HAVEN'T YET SEEN A COPY MYSELF).

I'VE FOUND MANY OF THESE VERY USEFUL; OTHERS SHOULD SUIT THE RESEARCH AIMS OF OTHER LIST-HUNTERS.

DAN WEDGWOOD
THEORETICAL AND APPLIED LINGUISTICS,
UNIVERSITY OF EDINBURGH

LL Issue: 14.1367
Date Posted: 13-May-2003
Original Query: Read original query