Publishing Partner: Cambridge University Press CUP Extra Publisher Login

Discussion Details

Title: Ross's Rule
Submitter: Joe Calabrese
Description: R.L Trask mentions two rules in 'Language: The Basics,' (pp. 34) one of
which is referred to by Trask as 'Ross's rule', or the complex noun phrase

1. Example: 'The guests who arrived in a car are ready to go home.'

Does Ross's rule say we can't ask a (grammatical question) about the car in
the relative clause?

How about 'Which car did the guests who are ready to leave arrive in?'

2. Concerning the 'complex noun phrase constraint': We can't ask a
question about the car in 'The rumor that John has stolen a car is
completely untrue.'

But, isn't the following a grammatical question about the car?

'Which is the car that the false rumor claims John has stolen?'

I appreciate any attention you might give to this.
Date Posted: 05-Mar-2010
Linguistic Field(s): Syntax
LL Issue: 21.1078
Posted: 05-Mar-2010

Search Again

Back to Discussions Index