Publishing Partner: Cambridge University Press CUP Extra Publisher Login

Discussion Details




Title: Re: 16.790, Disc: Re: Media: BBC: Welsh-Hindi Link
Submitter: C. Rajendran
Description: Yes,in all probability, the alleged similarity between the Welsh accent and Hindi [Urdu?Pakistani?] accents may be a matter of pure coincidence. But before closing the chapter altogether, shouldn't one consider the following issues?

1.Are there any language systems in the world, which, though thoroughly unrelated at any point in history, yet remarkably bear similarity in matters related to accent to such an extent that both could be mistakenly identified?

2.Shouldn't one consider the hypothetical possibility of two languages having something solidly common when they produce an accent appearing similar even to the untrained ear?

3.Linguistic history is replete with examples where we come across deep relationships when it comes to the question of the antecedents of languages.Consider the Gypsy language,which is identified as belonging to the eastern bramnch of IE. I shouldn't be the least surprised when one comes with a convincing theory that Finnish is very close to Dravidian languages one of these days! Jokes apart,the fact remains that, our planet earth is too small a place! However, I have no thesis to offer in this particular case apart from pleading for caution.

C.Rajendran


Dr. C. Rajendran
Professor of Sanskrit
University of Calicut
Calicut University P.O
Kerala 673 635

For previous messages in this discussion, see:
http://linguistlist.org/issues/16/16-790.html
http://linguistlist.org/issues/16/16-802.html

Original article:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/south_asia/4328733.stm
Date Posted: 17-Mar-2005
Linguistic Field(s): Historical Linguistics
Phonology
Genetic Classification
Language Specialty: English
Hindi
Welsh
LL Issue: 16.820
Posted: 17-Mar-2005

Search Again

Back to Discussions Index