LINGUIST List 16.48
Wed Jan 12 2005
Review: Applied Ling: Tedick (2005)
Editor for this issue: Naomi Ogasawara <naomilinguistlist.org>
What follows is a review or discussion note contributed to our Book Discussion Forum. We expect discussions to be informal and interactive; and the author of the book discussed is cordially invited to join in. If you are interested in leading a book discussion, look for books announced on LINGUIST as "available for review." Then contact Sheila Collberg at collberglinguistlist.org.
Second Language Teacher Education
Message 1: Second Language Teacher Education
From: Clemens Fritz <clemens.fritzclemens-fritz.de>
Subject: Second Language Teacher Education
EDITOR: Tedick, Diane J.
TITLE: Second Language Teacher Education
SUBTITLE: International Perspectives
PUBLISHER: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
Announced at http://linguistlist.org/issues/15/15-2992.html
Clemens Fritz, Freie Universität Berlin
'Second Language Teacher Education' (SLTE) is collection of papers which
derive from the Second International Conference on Language Teacher
Education held at the University of Minnesota in May 2001. The papers have
been expanded and improved by blind refereeing. The contributors are
mainly American, but the focus is not restricted to the US. Japan,
Australia and Great Britain as well as general studies are also part of
the volume. The papers are written not only by well-established,
internationally known scholars, but also by members of a younger
generation of researchers. Moreover, five out of eighteen chapters come
from practising teachers. SLTE brings together perspectives of teachers
and teacher educators in a variety of second language settings. Teaching
English as a Second Language (ESL), English as a Foreign Language (EFL),
foreign language education and bilingual or immersion education contexts
are all considered. In this the book is valuable since it furthers much
needed communication between research areas which, though closely related,
more often than not ignore each other. The international perspective adds
to this. The editor stresses (xxii) that "Second language teacher
educators are very aware that there are similar debates and efforts in the
world of first language education [...]". In this recognition lies another
fruitful approach to the topic of language teaching.
STRUCTURE OF THE BOOK
SLTE contains eighteen chapters in four sections. These are:
1. The knowledge base of second language teacher education.
2. The contexts of second language teacher education.
3. Collaboration in second language teacher education.
4. Second language teacher education in practice.
Each section is preceded by an introduction explaining its scope and
summarizing the respective papers. Naturally, some of the chapters
reflect all four themes but had to be put into one section only. This task
was carried out by the editor with much care. References are given at the
end of every contribution. The book closes with a helpful index divided
into an 'Author index', containing the names of all authors mentioned in
any of the chapters, and a 'Subject Index'. An index of abbreviations is
Section 1: The knowledge base of second language teacher education.
'Knowledge base' refers to what second language teachers need to know and
understand in order to be effective teachers. This, of course, has
implications for teacher education. The knowledge base comprises diverse
subjects such as theoretical knowledge, classroom experience, beliefs and
attitudes, values and ethical dispositions, teacher socialization and
learning, teacher cognition, teacher identity and reflective learning.
Chapter 1: Tarone/Allwright, "Second language teacher learning and student
second language learning: Shaping the knowledge base"
This chapter is largely a reply to Freeman/Johnson (1998) which has proven
to be very influential in the field of language teacher education.
Freeman/Johnson (1998) argued for a reconceptualization of the knowledge-
base of language teacher education since they saw that language teacher
education programs do not sufficiently reflect current research. Moreover,
social context as an issue is underrepresented. Tarone/Allwright are
afraid that the common goal, namely the influence of scholarly research on
educational practices, is undermined by the generalizing claims in
Freeman/Johnson. Tarone/Allwright believe that language teacher education
programs should be redesigned to avoid the 'Academic fallacy', i.e. the
belief that taking university courses alone makes an effective teacher,
and the 'Noninterface fallacy', i.e. the belief that only classroom
experiences make effective teachers.
The authors argue convincingly that teachers need to be educated
differently at different levels of their own teaching experiences. Their
second major point of disagreement with Freeman/Johnson is the assumed
virtual exclusion of the learners' position succinctly summed up in the
phrase "teach is not an intransitive verb; it is not an action one does by
oneself" (17f). A small reference error and a spelling mistake on p. 17
about Figure 2.1 in the book is unusual, since the book is carefully
Chapter 2: Freeman/Johnson, "Response to Tarone and Allwright"
It is also rather unusual that responses to a paper can become a paper of
their own. But this is an exception and not an unhappy one. The tone is
scholarly and clarifies where Tarone/Allwright misunderstood
Freeman/Johnson (1998) and where they agree to disagree. This response
indeed is a further contribution and was well-worth including. Only
citing the same, non-essential, quote twice in so short a paper seems a
bit odd (Prufrock: That is not what I meant at all).
Chapter 3: Scarino, "Introspection and Retrospection as windows on teacher
knowledge, values and ethical dispositions"
Scarino is interested in getting to know teacher knowledge, their values
and ethical dispositions. She does this by interviewing three experienced
teachers over a two-year period about their evaluations of a group of 30
students. Some interviews are done over a recently produced text,
introspection, others in retrospect. The insights gained are revealing
and will possibly stimulate further research.
Chapter 4: Johnston/Pawan/Mahan-Taylor, "The professional development of
working ESL/EFL teachers: A pilot study"
The authors intend to examine the lives of 12 graduates from a U.S.
masters program over a period of five years. There are two principal
research questions: "(a) What happens to teachers after the master of arts
(MA)? and (b) How do the careers and professional development of working
teachers match up with our assumptions about such teachers' needs,
interests, and concerns?" (54) The socio-political and socio-cultural
context of teacher development is divided into four parts: teacher life
stories, professional development, teacher beliefs and knowledge and
teacher identity. In this paper a pilot study about Bea, an American
teacher in Japan, is presented. Her interviews form the body of a corpus
of statements which is then further investigated.
Chapter 5: Freeman/Johnson, "Toward linking teacher knowledge and student
Freeman/Johnson differentiate between action, activity and tools. In their
words these three can be likened to: 1) action = passing a ball; 2)
activity = a whole soccer game, i.e. all actions and also tactics, etc.
and 3) tools = football, goalpost, etc. They stress that teaching, even
good teaching, alone does not necessarily lead to learning. Only the
active participation of the students of the language-classroom can achieve
this. The authors proceed with an example of a use of an overhead
projector as a multifunctional tool in language learning. They show how it
is effectively used by a teacher of French in a high school in Vermont.
Section 2. The contexts of second language teacher education.
'Context' means the contexts in which second language teacher education
takes place, the classroom contexts (ESL, EFL, etc.), and the geographic,
social, cultural, political and institutional contexts.
Chapter 6: Shohamy, "The power of tests over teachers: The power of
teachers over tests"
Shohamy discusses how tests are used by authoritative bodies to enforce
new policies. Teachers become mere instruments and their professional
qualifications and experiences are disregarded. Teachers need to be
emancipated and become critical users of tests.
Chapter 7: Hiramatsu, "Contexts and policy reform: A case study of EFL
teaching in a high school in Japan"
The author explores the impact of two recent reforms in Japan, the Japan
Exchange and Teaching (JET) Program and the revision of the English
curriculum towards more oral skills. Under JET, recent university
graduates from abroad are encouraged to come to Japan and fill the role of
team-teachers in foreign language classrooms. Not all teachers are happy
to have native speakers in their classrooms, since they are afraid of
being less knowledgeable than their team mates. The development of oral
skills are also hindered by the type of university entrance exams in Japan.
Chapter 8: Byrnes, Towards a comprehensive conceptualization of teaching
assistant education: Contents, commitments, structures"
Byrnes investigates foreign language teaching at the university level in
the US. She is especially concerned with the curriculum for graduate
teaching assistants and claims that language learning and culture learning
are too much apart and should be integrated much more.
Chapter 9: Poynor, "A conscious and deliberate intervention: The influence
of language teacher education"
ESL and bilingual education at the elementary level are looked at here.
The method of 'investigation' is rather strange. Poynor weaves her own
life story and that of two teachers into a narrative account of what they
experienced in classrooms using a particular teaching method. The value of
this is not immediately clear to the reviewer.
Section 3. Collaboration in second language teacher education.
This section stresses the importance of cooperation and collaborative
relationships. This encompasses institutional collaboration as well as
collaboration among teachers and teacher educators themselves.
Chapter 10: Edge, "Build it and they will come: Realising values in ESOL
This paper is very personal. Edge explores the political, economic,
military and cultural values typically associated with English and
compares them with his own set of beliefs and values. He concludes that
the teacher's convictions must take precedence and that discussions with
colleagues can help in this. Edge considers himself to be en vogue with
this procedure. Educators no longer want to say what is right or
wrong. "They offer their own evaluation and they invite their readers to
ask ... 'What can I learn from this'" (p. 182).
Chapter 11: Smith, "The impact of action research on teacher collaboration
and professional growth"
Smith documents the collaboration of three language teachers in an English
Language Institute in the U.S. The research questions are: "1. How does
the facilitated collaborative relationship of a triad of teachers
responsible for the same classes of students develop over 1 year? 2. How
do these teachers view the relation between their efforts to collaborate
and their professional development?" (p. 202) The 'testees' and the
students comment favourably on the outcome of the experiment. Importantly,
the teachers agreed to continue their cooperation even after the end of
the actual project.
Chapter 12: Cormany, Maynor, Kalnin, "Developing self, developing
curriculum, and developing theory: Researchers in residence at Patrick
Henry Professional Practice School"
The authors are two teachers and one researcher, all documenting the
results of personal development and collaboration Patrick Henry High
School, an establishment which managed to rise from bottom to top through
intensive efforts on part of the teaching staff. Researchers in residence
and action research are taken as important tools for developing teacher
skills and promoting the welfare of students and the school as a whole.
Chapter 13: Dubetz, "Improving ESL instruction in a bilingual program
through collaborative, inquiry-based professional development"
The last chapter in this section deals with bilingual classrooms in the
U.S. and the problems of learners of English whose first language is not
English. This is a very interesting topic and certainly needs more
attention. This type of language situation is quite frequent and teacher
education in this area is limited.
Section 4. Second language teacher education in practice.
The final section looks at how the work of second language teacher
education is accomplished. Program models and underlying philosophies are
showcased and examples given.
Chapter 14: Snow, "Key themes in TESOL MA teacher education"
Snow identifies six key themes of high quality teacher education. These
are (a) initiation into the professional discourse community, (b) the role
of native and non-native speaking teachers in the profession, (c) infusion
of technology, (d) knowledge of standards and accreditation processes, (e)
performance-based assessment, and (f) new partnerships and roles (p. 262).
Chapter 15: Cloud, "The dialogic process of capturing and building teacher
practical knowledge in dual language programs"
Cloud explores dual language education in the U.S. Particular attention is
given to school-based study groups, program visits, networking among dual
language teachers, curriculum development, and intensive institutes.
Chapter 16: Erben, "Teacher education through immmersion and immersion
teacher education: An Australian case"
Immersion as a way of teaching languages started in the 1960s in Canada
and is most prominent there and in Australia. Erben describes how
immersion teachers are educated in Queensland, Australia and critically
evaluates the courses' effectiveness. The method of immersion and the
type of teacher education shown appear exemplary.
Chapter 17: Bigelow/Tedick, "Combining foreign and second language teacher
education: Rewards and challenges"
Bigelow and Tedick showcase preservice and inservice programs for teachers
at the University of Minnesota. They argue for an integrated approach
which brings together ESL, ELF, bilingual and immersion teachers, since
contact between the different professions is profitable for all sides. The
rewards are found to outnumber the challenges.
Chapter 18: Walker, Ranney/Fortune, "Preparing preservice teachers for
English language learners: A content-based approach"
In the final chapter the diverse language proficiencies of students in a
classroom are addressed. For demographic reasons, there are many students
whose first language is not English. At the University of Minnesota there
are special courses to help content teachers to grapple with the different
linguistic needs of their students. In these courses the preservice
teachers are grouped in cohorts, of maths teachers, of English literature
teachers, etc., so that actual classroom problems can be addressed.
"It is hoped that these descriptions of second language teacher education
in practice will spark further ideas and innovations on the part of the
teacher educators who read this volume." (p 259; Tedick, the editor)
Although most of the papers are interesting in themselves and the editing
of the papers conforms to high standards, the above-mentioned hope needs
It is obvious that the publishing of conference proceedings with such a
broad scope make it impossible to build one coherent volume. Apart from
the notable exception of chapters 1 and 2, the contributions are almost
completely unrelated. This is interesting for a researcher who look for
many new approaches and research projects. For teachers and teacher
educators this is less than optimal.
Some issues are less well covered than could be wished. Multicultural and
multilingual contexts, an area of growing importance, come up only in two
chapters (13 and 18). In immersion and the development of language
skills of the general population, Canada and Australia take the lead. But
Canada cannot be found at all in the volume and Australia only in two
chapters (3 and 16), with chapter 3 not being Australia-specific. The
claim for an 'international approach' is further diminished when looking
at the papers in detail. Chapter 10 supposedly deals with Great Britain,
but is in reality a very theoretical line of arguments with no reference
to Great Britain whatsoever. Chapters 4 and 7 are about Japan, but in
chapter 4 there is only an interview with an American teacher in Japan
which intends to investigate her professional development. Chapter 7 alone
provides real insights into teachings at a Japanese school. Another issue
wanting is student needs and actual teaching. As rightly stated in chapter
1 "teach is a transitive verb". This is hardly visible in many of the
papers. Thus the editor's 'dedication' "This volume is dedicated to
teachers around the world who devote their professional lives to helping
others learn languages" (v) does not really capture the intended audience.
All in all, this book can be thoroughly recommended for researchers world-
wide. Teacher educators and teachers, however, may find it less useful
Freeman, D. and Johnson, D. (1998). Reconceptualizing the knowledge-base
of language teacher education. TESOL Quarterly 32, 397-418.
ABOUT THE REVIEWER
After studies in Regensburg, Germany, and Galway, Ireland, Clemens Fritz
graduated with a master's degree in English and History in 1995. For ten
years now he has worked and published on early Australian English. A
particular focus is on Irish English and its survival in Australia. In
1998 the reviewer started a two-year teacher training programme and has
been teaching English, history and drama in a German secondary school
Respond to list|Read more issues|LINGUIST home page|Top of issue