LINGUIST List 29.817

Mon Feb 19 2018

Calls: Philosophy of Lang, Pragmatics, Semantics/Belgium

Editor for this issue: Kenneth Steimel <>

Date: 19-Feb-2018
From: Philippe De Brabanter <>
Subject: Transparency Workshop 2018 – The Epistemic Transparency of Mental and Linguistic Content
E-mail this message to a friend

Full Title: Transparency Workshop 2018 – The Epistemic Transparency of Mental and Linguistic Content

Date: 13-Jun-2018 - 14-Jun-2018
Location: Brussels, Belgium
Contact Person: Gregory Bochner
Meeting Email: < click here to access email >

Linguistic Field(s): Philosophy of Language; Pragmatics; Semantics

Call Deadline: 10-Mar-2018

Meeting Description:

According to externalism (or anti-individualism), the contents of mental states are individuated in part by facts about the physical and/or the social environment in which the states are embedded. Externalism has become the dominant view in the philosophy of mind. Putnam's (1975) and Burge's (1979) thought experiments convinced most philosophers that subjects situated in relevantly dissimilar environments could be in the same (narrow) psychological states and yet think thoughts whose contents are true under different conditions. However, Boghossian (1994, 2015) argued that externalism conflicts with (comparative) transparency, the thesis that a thinker is able to know on a priori grounds, without the benefit of further empirical investigation, whether two of her occurrent thoughts have the same or different content(s). If the individuation of our mental contents depends on the environment, then, providing that we do not know a priori how our environment is, it should follow that (in the relevant, comparative sense) we cannot know a priori what we are thinking.

This result threatens a traditional account of self-knowledge which grants that subjects have privileged access to the contents of their own thoughts. One problem here, Boghossian claimed, is that externalism thereby blurs the line, to which assessments of rationality and psychological explanations are sensitive, between logical and factual errors (see also Kripke 1979). Given externalism, it appears that subjects who look intuitively rational will not be able to avoid some simple contradictions and invalid inferences without receiving more factual information about their environment. In response to this challenge, and among many other attempts, Stalnaker (2008) and Recanati (2012, 2016) have recently developed different compatibilist strategies purporting to reconcile externalism and transparency. Stalnaker's contextual and attributor-dependent account of content invokes tacit identity presuppositions to rescue the rationality of the subjects in the hardest cases (see the ensuing discussions in Boghossian 2011 and Stalnaker 2011). Recanati concedes that contents are opaque but argues that mental files, construed as vehicles of thoughts supposed to play some of the traditional roles of modes of presentation, are transparent. The aim of this workshop is to continue those ongoing debates and to seek new ways of reconciling externalism and transparency.

Keynote speakers:

Paul Boghossian (New York University)
François Recanati (Institut Jean Nicod)
Robert Stalnaker (Massachusetts Institute of Technology)

Topic: The epistemic transparency of mental and linguistic content
Areas: Philosophy of mind, philosophy of language, epistemology


Gregory Bochner (Université de Fribourg & Université Libre de Bruxelles), Philippe De Brabanter (Université Libre de Bruxelles), Philippe Kreutz (Université Libre de Bruxelles), Bruno Leclercq (Université de Liège), Sébastien Richard (Université Libre de Bruxelles), Antonin Thuns (Université Libre de Bruxelles). (

2nd Call for papers - Transparency Workshop 2018

Dates: June 13-14, 2018.
Venue: Université Libre de Bruxelles (ULB, Campus du Solbosch), Belgium.

We invite submissions of long abstracts in English of 1200 words maximum, suitable for one-hour presentations (including 15 minutes for discussion), on the (in)compatibility of externalism and transparency. Abstracts must be anonymous, in PDF format, single-spaced (A4), in a font size no less than 12. The abstracts should be sent to the contact address below, with your name, affiliation, and contact information in the body of the email. We cannot provide travel and/or accommodation grants.

Deadline for submissions: March 10, 2018
Notification of acceptance: March 20, 2018
Registration: free, but required; please email us at the address below.

Sponsor: Fonds National de la Recherche Scientifique (FNRS), Communauté française de Belgique, PDR T.0184.16 (2016-2020).

Page Updated: 19-Feb-2018