Publishing Partner: Cambridge University Press CUP Extra Publisher Login
amazon logo
More Info


New from Oxford University Press!

ad

Sorry About That

By Edwin L. Battistella

Sorry About That "explores why we apologize or don't and how our apologies succeed or fail."


New from Cambridge University Press!

ad

Sociolinguistics from the Periphery

By Sari Pietikäinen, Alexandra Jaffe, Helen Kelly-Holmes, Nik Coupland

Sociolinguistics from the Periphery "presents a fascinating book about change: shifting political, economic and cultural conditions; ephemeral, sometimes even seasonal, multilingualism; and altered imaginaries for minority and indigenous languages and their users"


Summary Details


Query:   English pretonic syncope
Author:  Katalin Balogne Berces
Submitter Email:  click here to access email
Linguistic LingField(s):   Phonetics
Phonology

Summary:   DEAR LINGUISTS,

A FEW WEEKS AGO I POSTED A QUERY ABOUT SCHWA-ZERO
ALTERNATION BEFORE STRESSED VOWELS IN ENGLISH. COUNTER
TO MY EXPECTATIONS, I GOT QUITE A NUMBER OF ANSWERS,
FOR WHICH I WOULD LIKE TO THANK ALL THOSE WHO DECIDED
TO HELP ME.

LEV BLUMENFELD WROTE ABOUT AN (INCONCLUSIVE) PHONETICS
EXPERIMENT ON INTONATION CUES TO THE CONTRAST BETWEEN
WORDS LIKE PRAYED AND PARADE. HE ALSO SENT THE WRITEUP
OF THE EXPERIMENT AND A LIST OF MINIMAL OR
NEAR-MINIMAL PAIRS. SUCH MINIMAL PAIRS ARE SEGMENTALLY
NEARLY IDENTICAL, ESP. IN FAST SPEECH: THEY RARELY
CONTAIN A FULLY VOICED SCHWA, AND THEY DIFFER IN E.G.
THE DURATION AND VOICING OF THE SONORANT.

IAN CROOKSTON DESCRIBED HIS AND A COLLEAGUE'S
INTUITIONS ABOUT THE PHENOMENON, NAMELY THAT IT IS
VERY OLD-FASHIONED AND POSH, AND THAT IT MAY BE MORE
RESTRICTED THAN POST-TONIC SYNCOPE AS FAR AS THE
FLANKING CONSONANTS ARE CONCERNED. E.G. FOR HIM P'TATO
IS IMPOSSIBLE IN ISOLATION.

VIKTOR TRON POINTED OUT TO ME THAT THE PROCESS CANNOT
BE DESCRIBED SOLELY IN TERMS OF PHONOLOGICAL
ENVIRONMENT BUT REFERENCE MUST BE MADE TO USE TOO
SINCE THE TENDENCY TO DROP THE SCHWA DEPENDS ON E.G.
FREQUENCY. ALSO, HE RAISED THE QUESTION OF WHETHER
THERE IS REALLY A CATEGORICAL NEUTRALISATION, WHETHER
THE INITIAL CONSONANT CLUSTER RESULTING FROM SYNCOPE
IN P'LICE IS THE SAME AS IN PLEASE. HE EXPRESSED HIS
DOUBTS AND REFERRED TO FRENCH, WHERE EFFECTS OF
PHONETIC CONSERVATION OF PROPERTIES HAVE BEEN
DOCUMENTED. THIS REMINDED ME OF A DISCUSSION ON
LINGUISTLIST (MARCH 2000) ABOUT UNDERLYING SCHWA WHERE
THE ISSUEE OF RULES THAT AREN'T 'TRUE ON THE SURFACE'
CAME UP, AND GEOFFREY S. NATHAN WROTE: 'CONSIDER, FOR
EXAMPLE, THE CONTRAST BETWEEN 'POLICE' AND 'PLEASE',
WHICH, ON THE SURFACE CONTRAST IN VOICING OF THE

(IGNORING THE IRRELEVANT FINAL CONSONANT DIFFERENCE).'
IN HIS ANSWER A.F. GUPTA HIGHLIGHTED THE IMPORTANCE OF
DIALECTAL VARIATION, SINCE THE TWO CLUSTERS ARE
HOMOPHONOUS IN HIS SPEECH (BOTH L'S ARE DEVOICED AND
BOTH WORDS ARE MONOSYLLABIC).
(HTTP://LINGUISTLIST.ORG/ISSUES/11/11-681.HTML)

HERB STAHLKE IS COMPLETING A PAPER THAT DEALS IN PART
WITH MY QUESTION: THE DEVOICING OF SCHWA IN POTATO,
DETROIT, SURPRISE, PERMIT, ETC. AND THE VOCALISATION
OF THE LATERAL IN POLICE, WHICH IS MUCH MORE
WIDESPREAD IN ENGLISH. HE ALSO ATTACHED A PAGE FROM
THE PAPER.

WITH THE HELP OF MIKE MAXWELL, VIKTOR TRON, AND ADAM
WERLE, I COULD COMPILE THE FOLLOWING LIST OF
REFERENCES:

BOLOZKY, SHMUEL. 1977. FAST SPEECH AS A FUNCTION OF
TEMPO IN NATURAL
GENERATIVE PHONOLOGY. JOURNAL OF LINGUISTICS 13.
217-238.

DALBY, JONATHAN. 1986. PHONETIC STRUCTURE OF FAST
SPEECH IN AMERICAN
ENGLISH. INDIANA UNIVERSITY LINGUISTICS CLUB.

FIDELHOLTZ, JAMES L. 1975. WORD FREQUENCY AND VOWEL
REDUCTION IN
ENGLISH. ROBIN E. GROSSMAN, L. JAMES SAN & TIMOTHY J.
VANCE, EDS. PAPERS FROM THE 11TH
REGIONAL MEETING OF THE CHICAGO LINGUISTIC SOCIETY.
200-213.

HOOPER, JOAN B. 1978. CONSTRAINTS ON SCHWA-DELETION IN
AMERICAN
ENGLISH. JACEK FISIAK, ED. RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN
HISTORICAL PHONOLOGY. MOUTON.
183-207.

DONCA STERIADE, C飩LE FOUGERON. 1997.

LL Issue: 13.971
Date Posted: 08-Apr-2002
Original Query: Read original query